Strategy in the Face of Chaos
Audio companions to my writing on strategy, technology, AI, cybersecurity and building technology businesses.
Each edition explores one of my published articles through an AI-generated discussion or debate, offering another way to engage with its central ideas. These are not interviews or original podcast episodes, and the voices are not mine. The written article remains the definitive version.
This channel is currently a pilot, and the format will evolve as I learn what works.
Strategy in the Face of Chaos
Your strategy has no competitors
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This pilot audio edition explores the argument behind Your Strategy Has No Competitors.
The discussion examines a common weakness in strategic planning. Organisations describe their own actions in detail while treating competitors as if they will remain still. Products launch, customers adopt, revenue grows and market share increases, but the companies that lose customers, margins or influence are rarely given a strategy of their own.
It considers why this happens through the concepts of the inside view and competitor neglect. Leaders understand their own intentions, capabilities and investment plans in depth, while competitors are usually reduced to their current products, prices and market positions. This imbalance can encourage overconfidence and make a strategy appear credible only because it assumes a conveniently passive market.
The discussion explores how the outside view and genuinely comparable situations can improve strategic reasoning. What happened when other companies attempted something similar? How quickly did incumbents respond? Which advantages remained valuable after competitors copied the visible features, matched prices or challenged the same routes to market?
It also introduces a practical test: give the other side a strategy. If your strategy succeeds, who loses? What incentives will they have to respond? What is their fastest and least expensive move? Most importantly, what advantage remains after their strongest plausible response?
The discussion argues for being competitor-aware without becoming competitor-led. Customer needs and organisational capabilities should still determine where to play and how to win. Competitive response provides the stress test that reveals whether those choices can survive contact with intelligent and motivated opponents.
This is an AI-generated discussion based on my published article. It offers another way to engage with the ideas, but it is not an interview or a recording of me. The written article remains the definitive version.
You know, if you ever watch a uh a highly choreographed movie fight scene, there is this certain undeniable magic to it. Like the hero ducks under a punch, they spin, they land this perfect, devastating sequence of strikes.
SPEAKER_02Right. It looks incredible on screen.
SPEAKER_00It does. But I mean, if you force yourself to watch closely and you ignore the hero and really just pay attention to the background actors, you know, the henchmen, you start to notice something entirely ridiculous.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Because they're literally just standing there.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. They are waiting their turn to be hit. Uh they might shuffle their feet a bit, they might look menacing, but they aren't actually fighting back until the script specifically tells them it is their moment to step forward and lose.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's a carefully coordinated dance masked as a conflict. I mean, the illusion of the hero's brilliance only works because the opponent is utterly predictable and, well, perfectly cooperative. Aaron Powell Right.
SPEAKER_00The hero is the only entity in the room allowed to possess any actual agency. And that makes for great cinema. But if you look at the average corporate strategic plan today, it's written exactly like that movie script. You, as a leader, are the action hero.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you are going to launch the product, you are going to lower the costs, and you're going to capture the market share.
SPEAKER_00And your competitors, well, they're just the henchmen waiting patiently in the background for you to win. So today we're taking a sledgehammer to that illusion. We are tailoring this deep dive specifically for you, the busy technology or business leader who knows that the stakes are high and who, frankly, needs to brutally stress test their own strategic thinking.
SPEAKER_02Which is so needed right now.
SPEAKER_00It really is. Our mission today is to completely deconstruct a truly profound article by Victor Holman titled Your Strategy Has No Competitors.
SPEAKER_02And Holman's central thesis here, it forces a total reframing of how organizations approach strategic planning. I mean, his core argument is that we have to fundamentally shift our focus away from our own internal, beautifully designed roadmaps. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_00Those perfect little PowerPoint slides.
SPEAKER_02Exactly the perfect slides. We need to look directly at the harsh external realities of a market that will inevitably actively fight back. Because we operate in a world that assumes competitors are frozen in time, and until we fix that, our strategies aren't actually strategies at all.
SPEAKER_00So we are going to unpack why this happens, how to recognize it in your own boardrooms, and most importantly, how to fix it. Let's start by unpacking this baseline flaw that Holman identifies, which is the assumption of an unopposed environment. Right. He points out that organizations plan for a future where they launch products, customers enthusiastically adopt them, revenue goes up, costs come down, and market share increases. It is a straight line pointing up and to the right on the chart.
SPEAKER_02Always up and to the right.
SPEAKER_00Always. And during this entire multi-year projection, the competitors remain exactly where they were on day one. So I have to ask: how does a room full of smart executives convince themselves of something so obviously false?
SPEAKER_02Well, the crazy part is that the corporate planning cycle itself actually manufactures this illusion.
SPEAKER_00Really? How so?
SPEAKER_02The very structure of how we build strategy creates a cognitive blind spot. Think about the mechanics of what happens in a typical organization. You have strategy teams that retreat into conference rooms for weeks, sometimes months at a time.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. Endless offsites.
SPEAKER_02Endless. They run complex financial models and Excel. They do exhaustive customer interviews, they debate the product roadmap. And through that intense, hyper-focused internal work, they inadvertently turn the chaotic living market into a sterile laboratory condition.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell A Laboratory condition, meaning like they are controlling for everything outside their own walls. Aaron Powell Correct.
SPEAKER_02I mean in a lab, you control all the variables except the specific one you are testing, right? Right. You want to see how a chemical reacts so you keep the temperature and the pressure constant. Well, in corporate strategy, teams treat their own company, their new initiative, their new pricing model as the active variable. Exactly. They pour all their analytical energy into modeling what that variable will do, but they treat the rest of the market, which includes highly motivated, heavily funded rival corporations as controlled static constants. They just assume the temperature of the market will remain exactly the same.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Okay, hold on. I have to push back here on behalf of everyone listening who has spent late nights building those strategy decks because we analyze our competitors constantly. It's a mandatory staple of any strategy presentation. We have the SWOT tables, right? Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats. We have those massive matrix positioning charts with the little bubbles showing who is where. We have entire annexes of slide decks dedicated to competitors. So how can Holman say we are treating them as static scenery? We are analyzing them to death.
SPEAKER_02Well, the nature of that analysis is exactly the trap Holman is warning us about. We analyze competitors, yes, but we analyze them as if we are taking a photograph.
SPEAKER_00A photograph.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. We document their current strengths. We document their current weaknesses. We catalog their current pricing tiers. But business strategy isn't a photograph, it is a dynamic movie. The distinction a Holman makes here is the fulcrum of his entire argument. Our competitor analysis tells us what our competitors are. It almost never asks what they will do.
SPEAKER_00Ah, what they are versus what they will do. So you are looking at a snapshot of a runner at the starting line.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And assuming they're just going to stay in that pose for the rest of the race.
SPEAKER_02That is the perfect way to visualize it. Once the strategy actually begins, once the clock starts ticking and you launch your initiative into the real world and your plan, those competitors suddenly stop making decisions.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_02Right. If you've documented a weakness in their supply chain and your SWOT analysis, you assume that weakness is permanent. You don't factor in that the moment you make a move and threaten them, they might uh hire a new supply chain leadership or acquire a logistics startup to immediately fix that weakness.
SPEAKER_00Or just completely pivot their delivery model.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. You treat them as active, formidable participants right up until the exact moment your strategy launches. And then conveniently you treat them as scenery.
SPEAKER_00That brings us right back to the movie fight scene. We scout the henchmen, we say, okay, the guy on the left has a slow left hook, the guy on the right is off balance, and then we script a sequence where we easily defeat them based on those static observations.
SPEAKER_02Right, assuming they won't adapt.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we assume they won't go home, train for six months, study our fighting style, and come back with a completely different approach while we are mid-punch.
SPEAKER_02And think about the practical financial reality of this for a technology leader modeling a massive investment. Like you might build a five-year revenue projection for a new enterprise software platform.
SPEAKER_00Very common.
SPEAKER_02You model out your user acquisition costs dropping by 20% in year three due to economies of scale. You model your churn rate decreasing as the product gets stickier.
SPEAKER_00It all looks great on paper.
SPEAKER_02It looks beautiful, but your financial model fundamentally assumes your top three competitors are just sitting in their offices, twiddling their thumbs for 36 months.
SPEAKER_00Just passively watching you take their enterprise clients.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And not changing a single variable in their own pricing, their feature set, or their marketing algorithms. It is an assumption of total passivity baked right into the math.
SPEAKER_00Which is wild when you flip their perspective. Yeah. Because if the roles were reversed, we would never just sit there. I mean, if a competitor launched a platform that threatened our core business, we would call an emergency board meeting.
SPEAKER_01Oh, instantly.
SPEAKER_00We would pull all nighters, we would reallocate marketing spend, we would do whatever it took to counter it. Yet we build plans assuming they won't do the exact same thing to us.
SPEAKER_02The disconnect is staggering when you lay it out like that. And this leads us to understand the most dangerous part of this peaceful future illusion. We treat competitors as static, but we completely ignore the exact trigger that wakes them up from that imaginary slumber.
SPEAKER_00And what's that trigger?
SPEAKER_02The very thing that forces them to act is the very thing we are trying to achieve, which is our own success.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Let's explore that trigger, because this introduces the paradox of success and the asymmetry of risk. Holman writes that every successful strategy changes the position of other people. This feels like a fundamental law of physics that business leaders conveniently choose to ignore.
SPEAKER_02It is an unavoidable zero-sum reality in many aspects of business, even in growing markets. I mean, value does not exist in a vacuum. If you gain significant market share, somebody else mathematically loses it. Right. If you introduce a radically lower cost model and win over consumers, somebody else suddenly faces immense unexpected pressure on their margins. Their board of directors starts asking them why their profits are shrinking.
SPEAKER_00The panic sets in.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. If you establish a new dominant technological platform, your existing suppliers and partners might suddenly lose their negotiating leverage and their influence over the ecosystem, your success alters the gravity of their world.
SPEAKER_00So if you remove friction for the end customer, suddenly your competitors appear incredibly difficult and antiquated to deal with by comparison. You've changed the baseline standard, which means you've changed their reality without them doing a single thing.
SPEAKER_02Precisely.
SPEAKER_00And Holman makes it very clear, the entities on the losing side of this equation will not remain passive.
SPEAKER_02Survival dictates action. They literally cannot afford to remain passive. If your strategy works and begins to effectively extract value from the ecosystem, the organizations losing that value will react with proportional force.
SPEAKER_00What does that look like in practice?
SPEAKER_02Well, Holman outlines exactly the kinds of maneuvers they are likely to deploy. They will brutally reduce their prices to bleed your margins. They will aggressively copy your best, most visible features to neutralize your differentiation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you see that in tech all the time.
SPEAKER_02Constantly. They will go to the market and lock up exclusive distribution channels to choke off your growth. They might change their contractual terms to trap existing customers and prevent them from migrating to you. Or they will precision target your most profitable, high-margin customers with bespoke, heavily discounted offers just to hurt you where you are most vulnerable.
SPEAKER_00Wow. So when I sit in steering committee meetings, we always talk about risk, you know, what is the risk profile of this project? Have we mitigated the risks? Holman is essentially arguing we are looking at the completely wrong side of the coin.
SPEAKER_02We are entirely focused on internal failure. This creates a massive asymmetry in our risk analysis. In boardrooms around the world today, leaders are asking very intelligent, probing, necessary questions about failure. Like what? Like, what if the core technology doesn't scale under load? What if the global supply chain breaks down? What if customers simply don't understand or want to buy this new feature?
SPEAKER_00Right, the standard risk checklist.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Those are failure risks. They're valid. But leadership teams rarely, if ever, ask the vastly more dangerous question, which is what if this works perfectly?
SPEAKER_00What if this works perfectly? That is such a chilling question to ask in a business context. Because if it works perfectly, you haven't just achieved a goal. You have kicked a hornet's nest.
SPEAKER_02If your strategy works perfectly, you are going to cause cascading existential panic in a rival's boardroom. Let's really unpack the strategic implications of that panic for the leaders listening right now.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Imagine your closest, most capable competitor. Your new, highly successful strategy just caused them to miss their quarterly earnings target for the first time in two years. Their stock takes a massive hit.
SPEAKER_01Ouch.
SPEAKER_02The CEO is suddenly under severe pressure from activist investors who want a turnaround. The VP of sales is looking at a pipeline that has dried up, and their entire team is going to lose their bonuses.
SPEAKER_00That's a nightmare scenario for them.
SPEAKER_02Right. So what are those people going to do? Are they going to politely applaud your strategic brilliance and concede defeat?
SPEAKER_00Not a chance. They are going to go to war. Their mortgages and their reputations are on the line.
SPEAKER_02And they will use unseen resources to fight that war. Holman notes a critical dynamic here. Competitors may use resources and relationships that were not visible in your original static SWOT analysis.
SPEAKER_00Because desperation unlocks new capabilities.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. A competitor might suddenly partner with a massive enterprise they previously viewed as a fierce rival, forging an alliance purely to block your momentum. They might convince their board to operate at a massive, unsustainable loss in a specific sector for a year just to drain your capital and force you out.
SPEAKER_00When corporate survival is genuinely on the line, the standard rules of engagement just disappear.
SPEAKER_01Completely.
SPEAKER_00You know, the grand irony here just hit me. The better your strategy is, the greater the incentive is for your rivals to destroy it. We chase unopposed action, but unopposed action is a total myth. Success isn't a finish line where you get to rest. Success is merely an invitation to a much more difficult conflict.
SPEAKER_02The more value you create and capture for yourself, the larger the target you paint on your own back. Holman states this plainly.
SPEAKER_00It's just a wish.
SPEAKER_02It is really just a fragile forecast of unopposed action.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so if success practically guarantees a violent competitive response, and if we are talking to incredibly smart, seasoned business leaders, which we are, why do they consistently feel to plan for it? Why is this blind spot so universal? We have to move from the symptom of the problem to the psychological root cause. Why are we so incredibly blind to this?
SPEAKER_02Well, it has nothing to do with a lack of intelligence. It is a fundamental cognitive bias regarding how the human brain processes different types of information. Holman leans heavily on the field of behavioral economics to explain this. He points out that companies inherently have a high-definition, vivid 4K resolution view of their own intentions and plans, but a grainy, low resolution, distant, abstract view of their competitors.
SPEAKER_00Let's really explore that contrast. What exactly makes our own internal view so high definition? What creates that 4K clarity?
SPEAKER_02You live it every single day. Organizations possess an intimate understanding of the deep, agonizing thinking behind their own products.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the endless iterations.
SPEAKER_02They understand the subtle nuances of their investment plan. They see the product roadmap stretching out for years, complete with all its contingencies and phases. They have sat behind the two-way glass during qualitative customer research, feeling the emotional resonance of the feedback firsthand.
SPEAKER_00They know exactly what technical capabilities are being painstakingly assembled by their engineering teams.
SPEAKER_02Yes. The internal narrative is rich, it is complex, and crucially, it is emotionally deeply felt because the leaders themselves forged it through endless debate, late nights, and profound effort. You have sweat equity in your own narrative.
SPEAKER_00There is blood, sweat, and tears in our own plan. We know how hard we worked on it, so it feels incredibly real and potent to us. And in contrast, how do we physically view the competitor from inside our own walls?
SPEAKER_02We view them from a vast distance, looking through a foggy window. We can only see what is currently publicly visible. We see their finished products sitting on a shelf. We see their current pricing tiers on their website. Right. We see their historical market share neatly formatted in an industry analyst report. But what is completely invisible to us are their future choices. We don't see their internal debates. We don't see their late-night whiteboard sessions.
SPEAKER_00We don't see the prototypes that failed and what they learned from them.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Their inner life is opaque.
SPEAKER_00Which biologically forces us to treat our own vivid emotional plans as reality and everything else in the market as just, well, a flat mathematical assumption. And Holman brings in the heavy hitters of behavioral economics here. Daniel Kahneman and Dan Lavallo. This is the concept of the inside view, correct?
SPEAKER_02The Kahneman and Lavallo concept of the inside view is the absolute cornerstone of this psychological trap. When decision makers adopt the inside view, which is our default human state, they build a highly detailed, compelling story around their own specific plans and assumptions. And the fatal flaw of the inside view is that they treat their specific situation as totally fundamentally unique.
SPEAKER_00Because they are so deeply immersed in the microscopic specifics of their own company's journey, they assume no one else's history or context can possibly apply to them.
SPEAKER_02Exactly the dynamic Kahneman describes. Leaders operating in the inside view give entirely insufficient weight to what has historically happened in comparable situations.
SPEAKER_00They think they're special.
SPEAKER_02Right. They look at industry history and think, well, sure, that company failed when they tried this, but we have a smarter management team, or we have a slightly newer technology, or our brand equity is different. So the old rules simply don't apply to us. The inside view prioritizes the internal narrative over external base rates.
SPEAKER_00I want to use an analogy here because I think it perfectly captures how this manifests in a business setting. It is the corporate equivalent of main character symbols.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's good.
SPEAKER_00We are the undisputed heroes of our own corporate story. We give ourselves these rich backstories. We know our complex motivations. We know how smart and adaptable our teams are. We know we have the freedom to change our minds, pivot our strategy, and take bold, unexpected action. But we view our competitors as NPCs, you know, non-player characters in a video game.
SPEAKER_02The NPC analogy is remarkably accurate.
SPEAKER_00We assume these NPC competitors are just running on basic, predictable programming. We picture them pacing back and forth on the exact same digital path, completely incapable of original thought, strategy, or adaptation. We have free will, they just have a loop of code.
SPEAKER_02We grant ourselves dynamic agency while modeling our competitors as rigid automatons, but Hallman introduces another layer of behavioral research that makes this bias even more insidious in a competitive business environment. He cites Colin Cammer and Dan Lavaller's research on overconfidence and the psychology of competitive entry.
SPEAKER_00Let's unpack that, because on the surface, confidence is a prerequisite for leadership. You can't lead a major initiative if you don't project confidence.
SPEAKER_02Confidence is necessary, yes, but in a strategic vacuum, it becomes a severe liability. Cameron Lavalla's experiments demonstrated a persistent phenomenon, which is that people routinely and drastically overestimate their prospects of success when that success depends on their relative skill compared to others.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so how do they test that?
SPEAKER_02Well, participants in these studies easily recognized their own abilities and strengths, but they gave far too little cognitive weight to a crucial fact. The other people voluntarily choosing to enter the market and compete against them were also highly confident and highly capable.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I want to challenge this from the perspective of an entrepreneur or a tech leader. If you are launching a startup or leading a massive, risky corporate transformation, don't you structurally have to believe you are better than the competition?
SPEAKER_02It feels that way, yeah.
SPEAKER_00If we sit around our conference tables second-guessing every move because we assume the other guys are just as smart, wouldn't we just be paralyzed? We would never launch anything. We need that confidence to act.
SPEAKER_02That is the most common defense of this behavior, but it misses the core finding of Kermer and Lavallo's research. The confidence itself isn't the actual problem. The problem is a profound blindness to mutual confidence.
SPEAKER_00Mutual confidence.
SPEAKER_02Right. Holman articulates this beautifully. We know exactly why our product is different. We know exactly why our engineering team is capable. We know exactly why our go-to-market plan should work. What we are completely blind to is the fact that our competitors also possess their own robust reasons for believing they can win.
SPEAKER_00Why our competitors also believe they can win, that is a completely different paradigm. They aren't sitting in their offices thinking, well, we're mediocre, our products are average. We just hope we somehow survive the year.
SPEAKER_02No. They possess their own 4K high-definition plan, they have their own sweat equity, they have their own brilliant engineers and aggressive sales leaders.
SPEAKER_00It's so easy to forget that.
SPEAKER_02It is. Competitor neglect, as Holman defines it in this context, does not mean you literally forget that competitors exist in the market. It means failing to attribute to them the same intelligence, the same ruthless ambition, and the same freedom of action that you naturally attribute to yourself when you are designing your strategy. It is, at its core, a failure of strategic empathy.
SPEAKER_00So if we are biologically and organizationally trapped in this inside view, blinded by our own main character syndrome and our high-definition internal narratives, how do we actually break out of it? This brings us to the antidote Holman proposes: hacking the bias with the outside view. What does adopting the outside view actually require a leadership team to do?
SPEAKER_02To effectively challenge the inside view, organizations have to force themselves, and it requires force, because it is unnatural, to look completely beyond their own internal narrative and rigorously examine comparable historical situations. Instead of just sitting in a room asking, how will our brilliant current plan unfold over the next three years? You have to ask a much colder, more sobering question. What actually happened when other companies attempted something fundamentally similar to this?
SPEAKER_00So we have to stop staring at our own beautifully formatted spreadsheets and look at the messy historical record. Holman provides some fantastic examples of these specific kinds of questions the outside view demands we ask. For instance, what happens when a new entrant tries to compete purely on a lower price in a mature, established market?
SPEAKER_02The inside view says we will capture 20% market share because customers want cheaper options.
SPEAKER_01Wow, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Another critical question Holman suggests. How quickly did massive incumbent giants actually respond when a startup introduced a product that was objectively technologically superior?
SPEAKER_00Did the giants just roll over and accept obsolescence, or did they crush the startup using their massive distribution advantages and existing enterprise relationships, regardless of the tech?
SPEAKER_02Exactly. The outside view demands you look at the base rate of success for your specific type of strategic maneuver. Another incredibly painful question Holman raises which of your unique advantages actually remain valuable after competitors inevitably copied the visible features?
SPEAKER_00That is a tough one to swallow. I mean, we launch a slick new user interface or a streamlined checkout process, and we model our financial projections, assuming that UI is a permanent competitive moat.
SPEAKER_02But it never is.
SPEAKER_00Right. But applying the outside view means looking at industry history and asking, when Company X launched a revolutionary UI five years ago, how many months did it take for every other major player to clone it? And once it was cloned, what competitive advantage did Company X actually have left to rely on?
SPEAKER_02Or consider the adoption of new business models. Holman notes we should ruthlessly ask, which business models looked incredibly attractive and highly profitable in theory, right up until three or four heavily funded companies decided to pursue them at the exact same time.
SPEAKER_00I immediately think of the ride sharing and food delivery wars over the last decade. Let's really look at that as a case study for the outside view.
SPEAKER_02Perfect example.
SPEAKER_00Because the unit economics look amazing when you are the only company modeling it in a spreadsheet. You calculate the cost of a ride, the margin, the customer acquisition. But what happened in reality?
SPEAKER_02What happened was that multiple well-funded entities pursued the exact same model simultaneously. Because the switching costs for consumers were essentially zero, I mean, you can have both Uber and Lyft on your phone, the companies had to aggressively subsidize both the drivers and the riders to maintain market share.
SPEAKER_00Just burning cash.
SPEAKER_02They engaged in a protracted multi-billion dollar war of attrition. The outside view tells us that when barriers to entry are low and capital is abundant, margin compression is almost guaranteed, regardless of how elegant your app is.
SPEAKER_00So the goal here is to build what Kahneman calls a reference class. But Holman is very careful to warn against a specific pitfall here. The aim of the outside view is not to go out and cherry-pick one flattering historical analogy that justifies what you already want to do.
SPEAKER_02Which is precisely what happens in most boardrooms.
SPEAKER_00All time.
SPEAKER_02Adobe moved to the cloud, and their valuations skyrocketed. We are the Adobe of the industrial plumbing supply industry.
SPEAKER_00You can justify almost any terrible, ill-conceived strategy by finding the one outlier success story that vaguely resembles your plan.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. True. Robust analogizing means constructing a reference class of genuinely comparable cases. You have to include both the rare successes and the catastrophic failures. You are trying to find the true objective base rate of success for this type of strategic move, stripped of your own optimism.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I need to challenge this from the perspective of a technology leader operating right now. We're in an era where the technological pace of change feels fundamentally unprecedented. Look at the explosion of generative AI over the last few years. If I am building an AI strategy today, how on earth can I use historical analogies or find a reference class for a technology that literally did not exist in its current form five years ago? Isn't the reference class just zero?
SPEAKER_02That is the most frequent and forceful pushback to the outside view, particularly in the tech sector, but it represents a fundamental conflation of the underlying technology with the resulting market dynamics.
SPEAKER_01What do you mean?
SPEAKER_02Anchoring back to Hallman's text, it is crucial to realize that while the technologies themselves differ wildly from decade to decade, the underlying market dynamics driven by human and corporate behavior endlessly repeat themselves.
SPEAKER_00So we have to separate the tool from the behavior the tool enables.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Generative AI is new, but a massive technological paradigm shift that drastically lowers the barrier to entry for content creation or software development, that is absolutely not new. We have seen this movie before. The printing press, desktop publishing software, the birth of the consumer internet, the launch of mobile app stores, these were all unprecedented technologies that triggered highly predictable market dynamics.
SPEAKER_00The tech changes, but the business reactions remain the same. Price wars repeat, margin erosion as commodity scale repeats, vicious battles over distribution channels and supplier leverage repeat, whether you are selling encyclopedias or AI APIs.
SPEAKER_02Holman readily acknowledges that comparable situations will never provide a perfect, crystal-clear, one-to-one answer. Industries do differ, specific organizational abilities differ. Timing matters immensely. But his core argument remains unshakable. Using imperfect historical comparisons is still vastly more useful and far less dangerous than clinging to the arrogant assumption that your organization, your brilliant team, and your current situation are entirely unique in the history of commerce.
SPEAKER_00It grounds you.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Imperfect comparisons act as a necessary cognitive shock. They force leaders out of their internal echo chambers and ground their projections in a realistic range of historical outcomes.
SPEAKER_00So we have established the psychological trap and we've explored the theory of looking at history through the outside view. But now I want to get hyper-practical. We're moving from the theoretical to a boardroom-ready, immediate exercise. If you are listening to this right now, this is the framework you take into the office tomorrow morning to immediately stress test your plans. It is the red teaming strategy test.
SPEAKER_02It is an incredibly elegant, simple, and utterly brutal test of any strategic plan.
SPEAKER_00Brutal is the right word.
SPEAKER_02Holman suggests a mandatory step, which is before you ever approve a strategy, before you allocate a single dollar of budget, and before you assign resources, you must write a short, formal response to your own strategy, but written entirely from the perspective of the competitor who is most threatened by it.
SPEAKER_00You literally have to role-play the enemy. You have to step out of your own shoes and inhabit their worldview. And Holman provides five specific probing questions you have to answer from their perspective.
SPEAKER_02These five questions force the outside view into a practical, actionable format.
SPEAKER_00I want to spend significant time walking through these five questions because they completely fliff the traditional planning script. Let's analyze them one by one and apply them to a hypothetical business scenario. Let's imagine a mid-sized B2B software company launching a radically new, automated feature that promises to cut their client's workload in half. Question one, if our strategy succeeds, who loses?
SPEAKER_02This first question is about precision targeting. It forces you to identify the specific victim of your success. In your software scenario, who loses? Is it your direct software competitor who suddenly looks outdated?
SPEAKER_00Or maybe someone else.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Is it an outsourced services firm whose manual labor you just automated away? Is it an adjacent industry you are bleeding into? You cannot prepare for a competitive response until you know exactly whose bottom line you are actively hurting. You have to find the geopolitical fault lines of your product launch.
SPEAKER_00You have to know who you are angering. Okay, question two, what incentives will they have to respond?
SPEAKER_02This ties directly back to our discussion on the asymmetry of risk. You have to gauge their level of desperation. If your new software feature only dents an adjacent competitors' revenue by 1%, they might simply ignore you. The incentive isn't there.
SPEAKER_00It's just a nuisance.
SPEAKER_02Right. But if your new feature threatens a competitor's core cash cow, the product that generates 80% of their profit, their incentive to respond is existential. Will their CEO lose their job if they don't crush your initiative? If the answer is yes, their response will be massive, immediate, and potentially irrational.
SPEAKER_00Wow, yeah. Question three is where it gets highly tactical. What is their fastest and least expensive response?
SPEAKER_02This is a critical question because corporate leaders often mistakenly assume strategic responses take years to build.
SPEAKER_00We think they'll just match our product.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. We assume they will try to build a better software feature, which takes 18 months of RD, but their fastest, cheapest response isn't to build a better product. It is simply to slash the price of their existing inferior product by 40% tomorrow morning.
SPEAKER_00And that changes everything.
SPEAKER_02That instant price drop can completely neutralize your premium value proposition while you are desperately trying to recoup your heavy RD costs.
SPEAKER_00They don't fight you on innovation. They just pull the rug out from under your entire pricing model. Okay, question four. Which capabilities or relationships could they use against us?
SPEAKER_02This question forces the team to look far beyond the obvious product-to-product or feature-to-feature comparison. Going back to your software example, maybe your competitor software is objectively clunky and old, but what if they have a 10-year exclusive ironclad relationship with the top five largest distributors or enterprise integrators in Europe?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's brutal.
SPEAKER_02They won't fight you on software quality. They will fight you by using those relationships to ensure nobody is legally allowed or incentivized to sell your superior product. They will leverage weapons you don't even possess.
SPEAKER_00And finally, question five. Holman highlights this as the most important question of the entire framework. What would remain advantageous after their strongest plausible move?
SPEAKER_02This is the absolute crux of the deep dive. You have to zero in on this specific calculation. What remains after the response? If your entire grand strategy relies on a neat software feature that your heavily funded competitor can realistically clone with a team of engineers in four weeks, you do not have a durable strategic advantage.
SPEAKER_00It's just a flash in the pan.
SPEAKER_02You have a transient advantage. You have a momentary gimmick.
SPEAKER_00I want to dwell on this idea of calculating ROI, you know, a return on investment in a post-retaliation environment. This feels like the most vital takeaway for anyone listening. In standard corporate planning, we calculate the ROI of a strategy based on the launch day. We look at the spreadsheet, we assume zero friction, and we project out five years of uninterrupted growth and profit.
SPEAKER_02And the mathematics of that traditional projection are fundamentally flawed. Hallman argues powerfully that the true value of any strategic move must be assessed after the likely competitive responses, not before them.
SPEAKER_00Walk us through an example of that.
SPEAKER_02Well, think about a classic lower price strategy. You decide to drop your prices by 20% to win massive market share. Your internal financial model calculates a fantastic ROI based on capturing 30% more customers.
SPEAKER_00Sounds great on paper.
SPEAKER_02But if your competitor can instantly match that price drop with an email to their sales team, all you have achieved is permanently reducing the profit margins across your entire industry.
SPEAKER_00You haven't won a strategic advantage. You have just impoverished everyone, including your own company.
SPEAKER_02Exactly.
SPEAKER_00Or consider finding a new route to market. You discover a clever, untapped digital marketing channel. The customer acquisition costs look incredibly attractive when you are the only one operating there.
SPEAKER_02Right, for a minute.
SPEAKER_00But as soon as you prove the channel is viable, your competitors see your success, flood that exact same channel with their own ad spend, and drive up the bidding costs until the channel is no longer profitable for anyone.
SPEAKER_02And Holman isn't saying you shouldn't make these moves. Lowering prices or finding new channels can be necessary. He explicitly says the original move may still be worthwhile. But you have to be intellectually honest with yourself and your board. You have to assess the strategy's true long-term value in the harsh post-retaliation landscape.
SPEAKER_00The goal of these five red teaming questions isn't necessarily to become a psychic and predict the future with 100% precision, is it? I mean, we can't know exactly what they will do.
SPEAKER_02Not at all. And Holman notes that competitors will often respond very differently than you expect. They might behave completely irrationally out of sheer panic, or, surprisingly, they might be so bogged down in their own internal bureaucracy and legacy systems that they fail to act all.
SPEAKER_00So what's the real goal?
SPEAKER_02The purpose of this rigorous red teaming exercise is not to forecast one exact guaranteed chess move. The true purpose is to discover whether your entire strategy fundamentally relies on everyone else in the market behaving conveniently.
SPEAKER_00That is the ultimate stress test.
SPEAKER_02If your brilliant plan mathematically requires your competitors to be slow, stupid, and utterly passive in order to succeed, it is a profoundly bad plan.
SPEAKER_00If your plan requires your competitors to be incompetent, you don't have a plan. So we are moving into the final and perhaps most nuanced part of Holman's framework: the imperative to be competitor aware, not competitor-led. Because after spending all this time telling our listeners they need to obsess over how competitors will react, we have to introduce Holman's vital caveat. If we don't, people might take the exact wrong lesson from this entire conversation.
SPEAKER_02It is a crucial, delicate distinction. If you take this advice too far, you risk allowing your core strategy to be dictated entirely by your competitors. Holman is very clear about the severe dangers of over-indexing on this. Organizations that watch their rivals too closely, who obsess over their every press release and feature update, almost inevitably become highly imitative.
SPEAKER_00That is a very real danger in corporate environments. I could easily see a leader listening to this, getting fired up, going into work tomorrow, and demanding the creation of a massive competitive response team for every single initiative. But if we spend all our time writing competitor responses and analyzing their moves, don't we just end up copying them? We become entirely reactive, playing endless defense.
SPEAKER_02When you let competitors lead your strategy, you inadvertently reproduce the same products. You start pursuing the exact same customer segments because you see them doing it. You even start adopting the same marketing language and industry buzzwords.
SPEAKER_00The dreaded convergence.
SPEAKER_02The grand irony here is that an over-reliance on competitor analysis creates industry convergence. Everyone starts looking, acting, and sounding exactly the same. That convergence destroys any chance of creating a unique, defensible competitive advantage, which is the exact opposite of the goal.
SPEAKER_00So how do we thread that incredibly tight needle? How do we obsess over their likely response to stress test our plans without letting them dictate our original moves?
SPEAKER_02Holman provides a brilliant clarifying separation of duties here. Strategy, its origin, its genesis, its core inspiration must always begin with an important challenge, a deep, unmet customer need, or a truly unique capability that your specific organization is unusually equipped to leverage. That is the wellspring of strategy.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so it starts internally or with the customer?
SPEAKER_02Yes. Competitive response serves an entirely different secondary purpose. It does not create the strategy, it tests the credibility of the strategy.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I love that operational distinction, the origin versus the test. It's the difference between where to play and how to survive.
SPEAKER_02Customer insight, technological innovation, and your unique organizational strengths dictate where to play and how to win. You build that in isolation based on value. But the competitive response test, the five questions we just discussed, determines whether your theoretical advantage is actually likely to survive in the wild.
SPEAKER_00So you do not look at the competitor to figure out what product to build. You look deeply at the customer. You build the product, you design the strategy, and then you ruthlessly run it through the gauntlet of the competitor's most likely, most aggressive response.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Imitation creates convergence and commoditization. True. Robust strategy is independently created based on genuine customer value, but it is rigorously, mercilessly tested against external threats before capital is ever deployed.
SPEAKER_00Holman has a fantastic grounding line in the text about this reality. He says competitors do not need to see your strategy presentation. They only need to experience its consequences.
SPEAKER_02That is the ultimate, unavoidable truth of the free market. You can keep your slide decks under lock and key, you can have strict NDAs, but the moment your strategy actually begins to work in the real world, the consequences will be violently felt.
SPEAKER_00Customers move, money shifts.
SPEAKER_02Customers will move their accounts, money will shift across the ecosystem, margins will shrink, and when they feel those consequences hitting their bottom line, they will make choices of their own.
SPEAKER_00Which brings us to Holman's ultimate summary of what actually makes a strategy credible. Because in the corporate world, we tend to think a strategy is credible if the PowerPoint slides look beautiful, or if the math checks out perfectly in Excel, or if the whole management team gave it a thumbs up and a round of applause at the end of the off-site retreat.
SPEAKER_02Internal consensus does not equal market credibility. A strategy isn't credible just because its internal logic is coherent and everyone in the room agrees on it. It becomes credible, as Holman states, only when that logic survives contact with other actors who have both the means and the existential incentive to make it fail.
SPEAKER_00Surviving contact with motivated, well-resourced actors who desperately want you to fail. That is the bar. If your strategy still works, if it still generates unique value after your competitors are allowed to think, choose, and respond with all their might, well, then and only then do you actually have a strategy.
SPEAKER_02And as Hallman brilliantly concludes his piece, until that standard is met, you don't actually have a strategy. You just have a plan for being left alone.
SPEAKER_00A plan for being left alone. That is a devastatingly accurate description of so much corporate planning today. It is the business equivalent of hoping it doesn't rain because you didn't feel like bringing an umbrella, rather than actually checking the forecast and preparing for a storm.
SPEAKER_02It is the ultimate tragic expression of the peaceful future illusion we started our conversation with.
SPEAKER_00Let's synthesize the journey we've been on today. We started by breaking down that persistent illusion of the peaceful future, recognizing that treating the living market as static scenery is a fatal flaw baked into modern planning.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00We explored the paradox of success, the reality that your own victories, the extraction of value, are exactly what will awaken a hostile, well-resourced response from your rivals. We dug into the psychology of the inside view and how our sweat equity and our main character syndrome blind us to the intelligence, agency, and mutual confidence of our competitors.
SPEAKER_02And we explored the necessary uncomfortable solutions, forcing ourselves to use the outside view by looking at the base rates of comparable historical situations to ground our optimistic expectations.
SPEAKER_00Employing the red teaming exercise to rigorously answer the five crucial questions from the perspective of our most threatened rival.
SPEAKER_02And finally, balancing all of this by ensuring we remain competitor aware, using their likely responses to stress tests or independently created value propositions, rather than becoming competitor-led and falling into the trap of imitation.
SPEAKER_00It is a massive paradigm shift. It takes strategy from being an internal, feel-good creative writing exercise and transforms it into an external, dynamic war game. For the leader listening to this right now, we have a direct, immediate call to action for you. Tomorrow morning, when you get to the office, take your current, most prized strategic plan, the one you are betting the quarter or the year on. Identify the single competitor who stands to lose the most money or market share if you succeed. And write their counterattack. Literally, write the memo their CEO is going to send to their executive team the morning after you launch. It might be the most uncomfortable but ultimately most valuable hour you spend this entire year.
SPEAKER_02It will illuminate critical vulnerabilities you didn't even know existed, and it will force you to finally ask the only question that truly matters. What remains of our advantage after they make their strongest move?
SPEAKER_00As we wrap up this deep dive, I want to leave you with a final thought that builds on everything Holman has taught us today. We talked at the very beginning about those movie fight scenes where the henchmen just stand around waiting patiently for the hero to act. If your current strategic advantage relies on a competitor taking more than six months to figure out what you were doing, or if it relies on the assumption that they won't have the budget, the brains, or the willpower to counter it, you don't actually have an advantage. You just have a head start. And a head start is the very first thing to disappear in a marathon. So look closely at your unique differentiator today. Look at the moat you think you've built around your business model. Is it truly an unassailable fortress that survives contact with a motivated, well-funded enemy? Or is it just a beautiful sand castle sitting quietly on a beach, completely ignoring the reality of the incoming tide?
SPEAKER_02A vital, uncompromising question for any leader preparing to enter the market.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive. We hope it gave you the perspective you need to truly stress test your plans and build strategies that actually survive the real world. Until next time, keep questioning those assumptions.